Paying a Speeding Ticket in New York State

Traffic court is totally a revenue scam in NY. The locality has to share the moving violation fines with the State, but they keep all the parking ticket money. They always plead first time speeders down to a parking ticket, and consequently everyone is always a first timer. The hard part is you have to appear in court (or send a lawyer).
Almost word for word what happened with my only speeding infraction in Milan, NY. I wen't to court because why the hell not and watched an entire court room of 30+ people all get pleaded down to more minor infractions. Didn't quite understand why this was happening at the time but this provides some solid context.
 
Just went thru this myself a few weeks ago. Here's a link to the Chautauqua DA's website where you can plead guilty and get a lessor fine. She will have to take an online test (boring as hell), but at the end of the day your fines will be less than simply having to pay the ticket. Both of my most recent speeding tickets I have done this and I had to mail in certified funds. I agree that it makes zero sense to have to do it this way but we are talking about government.

 
But don't you only get a ticket if your breaking the law? Not sure how that's a scam.
Quite awhile ago my mother, who was going to my grandmother’s house in Pennsylvania, got pulled over for going too fast in a small village between the finger lakes in The UpState.
Heard she just wrote a check payable to the local judge, (non-moving violation) allegedly. & Then she was back on the road again, EZ peazy.
It was before the intraweb.
 
But don't you only get a ticket if your breaking the law? Not sure how that's a scam.
IT's scam because everything they do is to maximize revenue, while (mostly) ignoring public safety. Speed limits are too low, are arbitrarily enforced and enforcement is concentrated on interstates but ignored in more dangerous areas, like city streets where pedestrian safety is a concern. How is pleading down a moving violation down to a parking violation so that the town doesn't have to share the fine with the State not a scam? Traffic enforcement is supposed to be about getting unsafe drivers off the road, but you can't identify them if you plead them all down.

Several years ago, due to various circumstances, I had 4 pending speeding tickets. The day before my first court date, the Albany newspaper has a front page article about how a local speed trap town pleads all the speeders down. So now I have to go to court the one day in 10 years that they won't make deals, and I get some bullshit "failure to obey a traffic control device" which is a moving violation. When I go for the second ticket, they give me a parking ticket and I'm exonerated. The judge there actually refused a guilty plea while I was there. The third judge sees the moving violation and he won't plead down. But the last case was the best. I figure it's gonna be "3 strikes and you're out," but the DA walks me up to the judge and offers a parking ticket. The judge asks me if I have a clean driving record and before I can answer the DA tells I have no prior convictions. How is that not breaking the law to maximize town revenue?

mm
 
...you can plead guilty and get a lessor fine. ..., but at the end of the day your fines will be less than simply having to pay the ticket. Both of my most recent speeding tickets I have done this...

Your fines aren't too much less for doing that. The real payoff is that you don't get a moving violation and don't risk higher insurance or losing your license.

mm
 
IT's scam because everything they do is to maximize revenue, while (mostly) ignoring public safety. Speed limits are too low, are arbitrarily enforced and enforcement is concentrated on interstates but ignored in more dangerous areas, like city streets where pedestrian safety is a concern. How is pleading down a moving violation down to a parking violation so that the town doesn't have to share the fine with the State not a scam? Traffic enforcement is supposed to be about getting unsafe drivers off the road, but you can't identify them if you plead them all down.

Several years ago, due to various circumstances, I had 4 pending speeding tickets. The day before my first court date, the Albany newspaper has a front page article about how a local speed trap town pleads all the speeders down. So now I have to go to court the one day in 10 years that they won't make deals, and I get some bullshit "failure to obey a traffic control device" which is a moving violation. When I go for the second ticket, they give me a parking ticket and I'm exonerated. The judge there actually refused a guilty plea while I was there. The third judge sees the moving violation and he won't plead down. But the last case was the best. I figure it's gonna be "3 strikes and you're out," but the DA walks me up to the judge and offers a parking ticket. The judge asks me if I have a clean driving record and before I can answer the DA tells I have no prior convictions. How is that not breaking the law to maximize town revenue?

mm
Gotcha
Makes sense
 
talking about scams, just got a 50$ speeding ticket in the mail. Speed Cams in NYC... at least there are no points attached to it..still it's a freaking money grab
 
Back
Top