That is fair, as I don't get the Smuggs hate.
If you want high speed lifts and wide open groomers, Smuggs is definitely not the best option. If you appreciate old school vibes, fixed grip lifts, natural snow, and some of the most challenging on map terrain in the east, Smuggs is the real deal. Add in some of the most technical off map tree skiing around plus extensive out of bounds and it has few peers.
Smuggs is a better "skier's mountain" than Stowe (excluding hiking to the ridge, than Mansfield gets the nod). I think MRG and Smuggs have more in common than MRG and Magic. The only thing Pico and Smuggs have in common is proximity to a corporate mountain, otherwise the two areas couldn't be more different.
For me, Smuggs is right up there with Jay, Cannon, and MRG as my favorites in the east. Difference between Jay and Smuggs? Smuggs has way better trees.